Orbital101 wrote:Just mind the edge of the cliff, if you get my meaning.
Mmmmm... lemmings. Wait, what?
The problem I see is not everyone local is on this site, those that are don't all check all the threads and many probably don't know this exists. Even if they do know about it there is nothing forcing them to follow it and there will always be people who disagree with what is in it. IMO making it into a PDF document or something wont make it any more accepted then the INAT FAQ which I have met several people who refuse to use it due to some of their interpretations. I am in the process of writing something similar to what you propose but its essentially house rules for anyone who plays at my place, there is no way it could be implemented city-wide or anything.
Also if the assault cannon and storm shield are the way they are in the DH book then that is what their point costs where designed for. Updating them to newer rules that are better without adjusting point costs goes against the entire point cost system. I mean look at BA terminators, they pay an extra 5pts for TH/SS that codex marines don't have to, so do we increase the points for codex marines or remove the 5pts for BA's?